Tuesday, January 24, 2012

It's A Nice Thought, Though

(I wrote this post last month, but decided at the last minute not to post it, because it was Christmas Eve, and I didn't think it was an appropriate time to rain on the Peace On Earth parade. Then I forgot to post it after the holidays were over. I'm leaving it as it was written on December 24, though, as they often do, my thoughts on the matter have eased back a bit.)

It's been six or seven years since I've seen Charlie Chaplin's The Great Dictator, but a few weeks ago I saw two references to it in as many days, specifically, this clip...



Inspiring and just as relevant today as it was in 1940, no? I got all inspired by it and decided to share it on the ol' Facebooks, but before I got around to it, I started a-thinkin'...

Here he is, talking about greed and cannon fodder as if it was a new development that we can overcome. But it's not new, and there's a reason why this is as relevant today as it was in 1940 - because human nature hasn't changed in the past 71 years. Or in the past 71,000 years. There has always been greed. There was always been those that would dominate others. Hell, you can see it happen with the runners-up in the Animal Kingdom Intelligence Competition, the apes and the dolphins. Did Charlie Chaplin really believe that the oppressed could unite against the "unnatural men" and bring about a world of peace and happiness?

Or, as Charlie Chaplin might say, has my knowledge made me overly cynical?

No comments: